A Framework for Constitutional Analysis
A practical framework for evaluating government action through constitutional structure: identify the acting level and branch, find the relevant power or limit, and consider other rules that may affect the result.
Identify the Actor, Power, and Constitutional Limits
A three-step check
When evaluating a government action, ask three questions in order:
Who acted? Identify whether the actor belongs to the national or a state government, and identify the branch.
What authority or limit applies? Locate the constitutional power or limit relevant to that action.
Does another constitutional rule affect the result? Check whether an additional rule changes the analysis.
Keep two dimensions distinct. concern how authority is organized among branches. concerns how authority is allocated between national and state governments. Because these are different dimensions, an assessment may need to consider both the actor’s branch and its level of government before reaching a conclusion.