Assessing Contract Breach
A practical framework for identifying contractual duties, determining when they are due, and evaluating nonperformance under common law and the UCC.
Identify the Duty and Whether It Is Due
Start with the duty, not the alleged
Before deciding that a party breached, identify the governing law and the contract term that creates the duty. Include a valid implied term where relevant. Then ask whether the duty was due: a may need to occur first, or may have been waived or excused. Only after establishing what was due, and when, can you compare it with what the party did.
A is an event that must occur, unless excused, before a duty arises or continues. A , by contrast, is itself a duty. Missing a may mean the dependent duty never became due; breaking a is nonperformance of a duty. A precedent comes before a duty arises, while a subsequent ends a duty that has already arisen.
Source example: If a buyer promises to pay upon delivery, delivery is ordinarily a prerequisite to the buyer’s payment duty. If the buyer prevents delivery, the seller may argue that the was excused. Whether that argument succeeds depends on the contract and applicable law.
Compare Under the Applicable Standard
Compare what was required with what happened
Once you have identified the duty and established that it was due, state the required and compare it with the party’s actual . Then assess the seriousness of any shortfall under the law governing the contract. The same nonconformity can have different consequences under common law and the UCC, so identify which standard applies before reaching a conclusion.
Under common law, substantial may satisfy a duty when the shortfall is minor and the contract’s central purpose has been achieved. A serious departure may instead be a material —one that can substantially defeat the other party’s expected benefit and may affect whether that party must continue performing. A minor , in contrast, may leave the other party’s remaining duties in place.
Hypothetical application: Suppose a service contract’s central purpose is achieved, but the work has a small shortfall. Under the stated common-law principle, that may count as substantial rather than a material . If the departure instead seriously defeats the expected benefit, it may be material. The facts and applicable law determine which description fits.
For a sale of goods, the UCC generally permits a buyer to reject goods that fail to conform in any respect. Do not substitute common law’s substantial- approach for this general UCC rule. Rejection remains subject to statutory rules and exceptions, including rules for installment contracts and agreed limitations of remedy.