Framing a Decision Neutrally
How to define a decision clearly and neutrally before comparing possible solutions.
State the Problem Before Choosing a Solution
A decision is easier to compare fairly when its problem is stated before any preferred solution. A neutral frame identifies what choice must be made, who will decide, and when. It also names the people or systems affected and sets the scope of the choice. Most importantly, it describes the underlying problem or opportunity without building a proposed answer into the question.
For example, “Should the city reduce peak-hour delays on the east-west corridor, and how?” identifies the problem while leaving the method open. The city can then consider different ways to address delays. By contrast, “Should the city widen the highway?” frames the issue around one solution. That wording may exclude other approaches before they have been compared.
A useful check is to ask: Would this question still make sense if the decision-maker chose a different approach—or no new action? If not, the framing may be assuming a solution. Keeping the problem and the proposed remedy distinct gives later comparison room to examine alternatives on their merits.