Timedora

Judicial Review: Courts and the Constitution

A lesson on how courts apply the Constitution to government action in cases properly before them, including the reasoning behind judicial review and its role in protecting constitutional rights.

How Courts Apply the Constitution

The constitutional basis for review

is the power of courts to assess whether government action is consistent with the Constitution. The Constitution does not use the phrase “,” but Article III authorizes federal courts to decide cases arising under the Constitution, and makes the Constitution the supreme law of the land. Together, these provisions support courts applying the Constitution when they resolve cases within their authority.

In Marbury v. Madison (1803), the Supreme Court established its authority to review federal laws in cases before it. Chief Justice John Marshall reasoned that a written Constitution could not be supreme if Congress could override it by passing an inconsistent law. If a law conflicts with the Constitution, the Constitution must govern the court’s decision.

Review is not limited to acts of Congress. When a properly presented case raises a constitutional issue, courts may assess executive action and state laws as well. A constitutional dispute might concern the limits of government power or an individual right—but the court addresses it as part of resolving the case, not as a general review of policy.

What review can do—and when courts use it

A court’s ruling need not always strike down the challenged action. Depending on the case, the court may invalidate a law or action, uphold it, or interpret it in a way that resolves the dispute without invalidating it. In each instance, the court is deciding the legal issue needed to settle the case before it.

Brown v. Board of Education (1954) illustrates protecting an individual right. The Supreme Court held that state-mandated racial segregation in public schools violated the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The case shows how applying the Constitution can limit government action when that action infringes a constitutional right.

The case-based nature of review is an important limit: courts do not issue general advice to the other branches about what the Constitution means in hypothetical situations. They interpret it while deciding disputes properly before them. Thus, is both a way to enforce constitutional limits and a power exercised through actual cases.