Timedora

Rights-Based Governance in Conservation

A lesson on rights, decision-making authority, participation, equity, and conflict resolution in conservation.

Who Decides, and Whose Rights Count?

Conservation decisions affect places where people live, work, maintain cultural connections, and exercise rights. So evaluating conservation means looking beyond ecological goals: who makes decisions, whose knowledge is considered, and who bears costs or receives benefits? Target 3 of the Kunming–Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework calls for equitably governed protected and conserved areas that recognize and respect Indigenous Peoples’ and local communities’ rights, including rights over traditional territories.

describes arrangements in which local communities have a meaningful role in setting priorities, making decisions, managing resources, or monitoring outcomes. But the arrangements differ in where authority rests:

Who holds decision-making authority?
ArrangementAuthorityCommunity role
Community-ledCommunity directs conservation in its territoryUses its own institutions and knowledge
Co-managementCommunity and government share responsibilities and authorityWorks under agreed rules
Consultative participationAuthorities retain most decision-making powerProvides input
The key distinction is where decision-making responsibility and authority reside.

These are not interchangeable. A consultation may provide an opportunity to speak, but it does not by itself give a community authority over the decision. To assess governance, ask: Who has recognized rights? Who can make or challenge decisions? Are agreed rules enforceable? Some Indigenous and community conserved territories are governed through customary institutions rather than established as state protected areas; government ownership is not the only valid model.

The rights that conservation decisions need to recognize may come from national law, customary tenure, long-standing use, or cultural and spiritual relationships with a territory. Customary rights can include access to places, harvesting resources, seasonal use, governance, and responsibilities to care for places. Thus, rights are not limited to formal title deeds. When rights are undocumented or unrecognized, conservation boundaries and restrictions can displace people or limit livelihoods.

The United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples affirms Indigenous Peoples’ rights to lands, territories, and resources they have traditionally owned, occupied, or used. It calls for legal recognition that respects their customs and tenure systems. It also provides for redress—including restitution or fair compensation—where lands or resources have been taken or damaged without free, prior, and informed consent. The practical lesson is that conservation planning should identify the rights and governance already connected to a place, rather than assuming that a lack of formal documentation means no rights exist.

Understanding FPIC

describes conditions for decision-making by Indigenous Peoples in relevant contexts:

  • Free: people are able to make decisions freely.

  • Prior: the decision can be made before the relevant action is taken.

  • Informed: adequate information is available to support the decision.

The United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples calls for good-faith consultation and cooperation to obtain consent in specified contexts, including decisions affecting Indigenous lands and resources. The biodiversity framework also says Indigenous and local knowledge should be accessed with FPIC, in accordance with relevant law.

FPIC is not a one-time meeting that merely presents information. Its meaning depends on a process in which people can decide freely, in time to matter, and with adequate information. The specific legal requirements vary with the applicable international and national framework, so the principle should not be treated as a single formula that applies identically in every situation.

Participation and Three Dimensions of

begins early—while conservation options and boundaries are still being considered—and continues through implementation, monitoring, and review. Starting early matters because people need an opportunity to influence decisions, not just react after choices have already been made. Participation also requires accessible information, sufficient time, culturally appropriate processes, and the ability to affect decisions.

Representation matters too. Processes should include groups whose voices might otherwise be overlooked, including women, youth, people with disabilities, and people who rely on resources but lack formal land titles. In other words, inviting people to a meeting is not enough if they cannot access the information or process, or cannot meaningfully influence the outcome.

has three connected dimensions:

  1. Procedural concerns whether people can participate fairly and influence decisions.

  2. Recognitional concerns whether diverse identities, rights, institutions, knowledge systems, and values are respected.

  3. Distributive concerns whether conservation costs, restrictions, and benefits are shared fairly.

These dimensions help diagnose different shortcomings. For example, a process might offer participation but fail to respect customary rights; alternatively, it might recognize rights in principle while leaving affected people with an unfair share of restrictions or costs.

Consider the source example of a protected area that limits fishing. Equitable governance requires more than offering fishers alternative income. It involves recognizing legitimate fishing rights, involving affected fishers in setting rules, considering food security and cultural practices, and ensuring accessible ways to challenge unfair decisions. This example brings the dimensions together: fishers need influence over rule-making, their rights and practices need recognition, and the costs of restrictions must be considered fairly.

Benefit-sharing can support , but it does not automatically replace rights or resolve a failure to obtain consent where consent is required. A benefit does not, by itself, answer whether a right was respected or whether people had a meaningful role in the decision.

Preventing and Resolving Land and Resource Conflicts

Conservation-related conflict can arise when protected-area rules overlap with customary territories, restrict farming, grazing, fishing, gathering, or access to culturally important places, or distribute tourism and conservation revenue unequally. Disputes can also involve competing claims among communities, government agencies, companies, and conservation organizations. When tenure is insecure, these conflicts are harder to resolve and the risk of dispossession can increase.

A rights-based approach treats conflict prevention as part of good governance. Practical safeguards include:

  • recognizing before imposing new restrictions;

  • mapping resource use with affected rights-holders;

  • disclosing proposed rules and likely impacts;

  • agreeing on decision-making and benefit-sharing arrangements;

  • monitoring social as well as ecological outcomes; and

  • providing accessible grievance and dispute-resolution processes.

These steps connect rights recognition with practical decision-making: map who uses and governs an area, explain what is proposed, and create ways to negotiate and review the consequences. The FAO Voluntary Guidelines on the Responsible Governance of Tenure recommend recognizing and safeguarding , enabling participation, and providing access to justice.

Worked case: a reserve and customary grazing land

Suppose a proposed reserve overlaps with a community’s customary grazing area. A rights-based process would first identify who uses and governs the area and recognize customary claims. It would assess ecological needs alongside the community’s livelihood needs, rather than treating one as automatically invalid because the other is present.

Community representatives and relevant authorities could then negotiate boundaries, seasonal access, grazing rules, monitoring responsibilities, and a process for resolving disputes. These are the issues that determine how conservation rules would work in practice and how people could respond if problems arise. If agreement is not reached, the process should provide a fair way to review the decision. The community’s use should not be treated as automatically illegitimate merely because agreement over proposed rules has not been reached.

The broader principle is that conservation is more durable when communities are recognized as rights-holders and partners, not merely as stakeholders to be consulted. Shared governance, secure rights, inclusive participation, fair treatment, and effective ways to resolve disputes help align conservation goals with the people who live in and care for the places involved.

  • : Rights relating to land and resources, which may include access, harvesting, seasonal use, governance, and responsibilities to care for places.

  • : A process for raising concerns and seeking review or resolution when people believe a decision or its effects are unfair.