Timedora

Three Dimensions of Justice

Explains how redistribution, recognition, and representation address different forms of injustice and how to distinguish their remedies.

Three dimensions, three kinds of remedy

Diagnose the barrier before choosing a remedy

, , and name three different dimensions of injustice. To decide which is relevant, first ask what barrier people face: unequal access to resources, unequal social standing, or exclusion from political voice and decision-making. A single situation can involve more than one dimension, so these are diagnostic distinctions—not boxes that every problem or remedy must fit into exclusively.

concerns resources such as income, employment, education, housing, and time. In the transit example, funding accessible vehicles and stations responds to a material barrier: the resources and infrastructure needed for access.

concerns status inequality: whether norms or practices treat people as inferior or stigmatize them. The remedy is not simply praise or automatic approval of every identity claim. It is to change discriminatory laws, institutional practices, and public norms so people can participate as social equals. In transit, challenging the idea that disabled people’s mobility is optional addresses a demeaning assumption, not the funding question itself.

asks whose interests and experiences count, who has effective political voice, and who gets to define the boundaries and rules of debate. is a lack of effective political voice. is more specifically about who is included in the political community entitled to decide: it occurs when people affected by decisions are excluded from having a say. Including disabled riders in setting transit priorities addresses whose input shapes policy.

The three remedies complement one another: funding access does not by itself ensure equal standing or a voice in decisions, while voice alone does not provide the resources needed for access. Identifying each barrier helps show what a response may still leave unresolved.

Three dimensions in one transit example
DimensionBarrier it addressesRemedy directionDisabled-transit example
RedistributionUnequal access to resourcesSocial programs, labor protections, or changes to taxation or ownershipFund accessible vehicles and stations
RecognitionDemeaning or stigmatizing norms and practicesChange discriminatory laws, institutional practices, or public normsChallenge the assumption that disabled people’s mobility is optional
RepresentationPolitical exclusion and lack of influence over decisionsInclude affected people’s interests and voices in decision-makingInclude disabled riders in setting transit priorities
Three distinct dimensions of justice applied to the source’s disabled-transit example; a single situation can involve all three.