Timedora
Free Online Flashcard Deck

Tort Causation and Scope of Liability Free Online Flashcards

Study Tort Causation and Scope of Liability with 12 free online flashcards. Review key terms, definitions, and concepts with this interactive flashcard deck.

12 cards
01
Front

What does factual causation ask?

Back

Factual causation asks whether the defendant’s conduct contributed to the harm as a matter of fact.

02
Front

What does scope of liability ask?

Back

Scope of liability asks whether the law should hold the defendant responsible for the harm.

03
Front

How do factual causation and scope of liability differ?

Back

Factual causation asks whether the conduct helped cause the harm; scope of liability asks whether the law assigns responsibility for that harm.

04
Front

What is the but-for test?

Back

The but-for test asks whether the harm would have occurred if the defendant had not acted as they did. If it would have occurred anyway, the conduct ordinarily is not a factual cause.

05
Front

Would running a red light be a but-for cause if the collision would occur anyway?

Back

No. If the collision would have occurred at the same time and place even if the driver had stopped, running the red light was not a but-for cause.

06
Front

Why can the but-for test fail when two fires each suffice to destroy a house?

Back

A simple but-for test may fail because removing either fire still leaves the other sufficient fire. Courts address such cases through rules for multiple sufficient causes.

07
Front

In multiple-sufficient-cause cases, what does the substantial-factor formulation address?

Back

Some courts use a substantial-factor formulation to address multiple sufficient causes. That formulation concerns factual causation, not scope of liability.

08
Front

Must a defendant be the sole factual cause of harm?

Back

No. Another person’s act, the plaintiff’s conduct, or a natural event may also contribute; the defendant’s conduct need not be the sole factual cause.

09
Front

What limits a defendant’s responsibility under scope of liability?

Back

Scope of liability generally limits responsibility to harms that result from the risks that made the conduct wrongful.

10
Front

In negligence, what risk-based question helps determine scope of liability?

Back

In negligence, ask whether the plaintiff’s harm was among the risks that made the defendant’s conduct unreasonable. The inquiry focuses on the kind of harm and its causal pathway.

11
Front

What does the eggshell-plaintiff rule require?

Back

When the type of harm falls within the scope of the risk, the defendant generally takes the plaintiff as found, including the plaintiff’s particular vulnerability.

12
Front

What is an intervening cause?

Back

An intervening cause is an event occurring after the defendant’s conduct that also contributes to the harm.