Timedora

Factual Cause and Scope of Liability

A focused guide to the two distinct causation questions in tort law: whether conduct factually contributed to harm and whether the law places that harm within the defendant’s responsibility.

Two distinct causation questions

Two questions, not one

A tort claim generally requires a connection between the defendant’s wrongful conduct and the plaintiff’s harm. Courts analyze that connection through two distinct inquiries:

  1. : Did the conduct help cause the harm as a matter of fact?

  2. : Should the law hold the defendant responsible for this harm?

A “yes” to the first does not automatically answer the second. The terminology and tests vary among jurisdictions, but keeping the questions separate helps clarify the analysis.

First:

The usual factual-cause test is the but-for test: Would the harm have occurred but for the defendant’s conduct? If the harm would have happened anyway, the conduct ordinarily is not a factual cause under this test.

For example, suppose a driver runs a red light, but the collision would have occurred at the same time and place even if the driver had stopped. Compare the actual situation with that counterfactual—what would have happened if the driver had stopped? Because the collision still would have occurred, the red-light violation is not a but-for cause of that collision.

Second:

Even if conduct factually contributed to a harm, the law does not necessarily assign responsibility for every consequence connected to it. asks whether the harm resulted from risks that made the conduct wrongful. In negligence, the question is whether the plaintiff’s harm was among the risks that made the defendant’s conduct unreasonable. This is about the kind of harm and how it occurred, not merely whether some consequence could be imagined.

For instance, a negligently parked vehicle blocking a road may create a risk of collision. A collision resulting from the obstruction may fall within that risk. A highly unusual, unrelated injury resulting from the obstruction may not. The answer depends on the facts and governing law.

This two-part framework is especially prominent in negligence. For intentional torts, courts may assess scope in light of the particular tort and the harms the defendant intended or risked; jurisdiction-specific rules apply. An intervening act does not, by itself, erase responsibility for an intentional tort.