Timedora

Generating and Recording Design Concepts

A practical guide to generating meaningfully different concepts, recording them clearly, and keeping early evaluation from narrowing the options too soon.

Explore Before You Evaluate

Why explore first?

Begin concept generation with : deliberately develop several different ways to meet the need before judging them. The aim is not simply to make a long list. Ideas should differ in their basic operating principle, not merely in appearance. Separating generation from evaluation also prevents early criticism from narrowing the options before the team has explored them.

For example, a lunch-carrying solution could keep food cold through insulation, a removable chilled insert, refrigeration at the destination, or meal delivery near lunchtime. These concepts address the same need in meaningfully different ways. Once they have been recorded, the team can evaluate them against the need and its constraints.

Techniques for widening the options

  • Brainstorming gathers ideas around one focused question. Defer judgment, build on suggestions, and aim to generate many ideas before evaluating them.

  • Brainwriting follows the same idea-generation principles, but participants first record ideas individually. This can broaden participation by giving people a chance to contribute before group discussion.

  • Analogy and “what if?” prompts invite the team to borrow principles from other settings. For the lunch example, consider how a thermos, a delivery system, or a hospital supply chain manages temperature or timing. The prompt is a way to find possible approaches, not proof that an approach will work in the new setting.

  • A starts by breaking the problem into functions. For a lunch solution, these might include containing food, controlling temperature, and transporting it. List alternative ways to perform each function, then combine compatible choices. Such combinations can reveal concepts the team did not initially think of.

Record concepts before comparing them

Keep a visible record, giving each concept a short name and noting its basic operating principle, intended user, and important assumptions. These details make it possible to understand what the idea proposes and what would need checking later. Keep the record during generation, but postpone evaluation: the purpose at this stage is to preserve a useful range of distinct concepts, not to select a winner.