Inchoate and Accomplice Liability
How attempt, solicitation, conspiracy, and accomplice liability differ, and how merger rules affect multiple convictions.
Four Theories, Four Distinct Requirements
Four theories, four distinct requirements
These theories can arise from overlapping conduct, but each asks a different question about what the person did and intended:
: Did the person intend to commit a target crime and take a sufficiently substantial—or otherwise sufficiently direct—step toward committing it? The focus is on movement toward the target crime.
: Did the person intentionally ask or urge someone else to commit a crime? does not depend on the other person accepting.
: Did the person agree with someone else to pursue an unlawful objective? An overt act is required only if the governing law says so.
: Did the person intentionally help or encourage another person’s offense, with the mental state required for that particular offense? The focus is on assistance or encouragement, not merely on being nearby or involved in some way.
The getaway-driver example shows why assistance alone is not enough. A person who knowingly serves as a driver for a planned robbery may be liable as an accomplice if the required intent is proved: the person’s driving assists the robbery, and the person knows about the plan. By contrast, someone who happens to drive a robber away without knowing about the robbery is not liable on that basis merely because the ride helped.
The precise mental-state rule depends on the offense and jurisdiction. For example, Rosemond v. United States described federal aiding-and-abetting liability as requiring an affirmative act in furtherance of the offense and intent to facilitate it. In the specific firearm offense before it, the Court also addressed what the defendant had to know and when. That case-specific rule should not be assumed to apply to every crime or jurisdiction.
A useful distinction: an agreement points to ; an effort to persuade points to ; a step toward personally committing the crime points to ; and intentional assistance or encouragement points to . Identify the applicable law before deciding whether the elements are met.
and Multiple Convictions
and multiple convictions
When the target crime is completed, traditional rules generally treat and as merging into that completed offense for purposes of multiple convictions. In general, that means a person is not separately convicted of the or as well as the completed target offense under those traditional rules.
generally does not merge into the completed target offense, so multiple convictions may be possible for and the completed crime. The distinction reflects the different theory: centers on an agreement, while and are generally treated as merging into the completed target crime.
These are general principles, not automatic outcomes. The applicable statute and the jurisdiction’s doctrine control; check them before concluding whether separate convictions are allowed.