Sources of U.S. Criminal Law
Explains where U.S. criminal law comes from, what each source contributes, and the limits that apply across federal and state jurisdictions.
Where Criminal Law Comes From
Different sources, different roles
U.S. criminal law comes chiefly from constitutions, statutes, regulations, and judicial decisions. These sources do not all do the same job.
Constitutions establish government powers and limits. The federal and state constitutions constrain how crimes may be defined, investigated, tried, and punished.
Statutes enacted by Congress or state legislatures define most crimes and their penalties. Federal criminal statutes are principally collected in Title 18 of the U.S. Code; states have their own criminal codes. For example, to identify a crime’s requirements, begin with the governing statute rather than assuming a general rule applies everywhere.
Regulations can supplement statutes, but an agency cannot make a violation criminal on its own: a legislature must authorize the agency to issue rules, and a statute must make violations punishable. The statute and therefore need to be read together.
Courts, common law, and jurisdiction
Judicial decisions interpret constitutions, statutes, and regulations, clarify the elements of offenses, and develop procedural and constitutional rules. Their interpretive role does not mean that courts may freely invent crimes. In states that recognize common-law crimes, common law may inform or supply crime definitions. Federal courts, by contrast, cannot create new federal common-law crimes; Congress must establish a federal offense by law.
The is influential as a model for drafting and interpreting criminal codes, but it is not law unless a jurisdiction adopts its provisions. In practice, the governing sources and rules can differ between federal and state jurisdictions. Always identify the jurisdiction, then check the applicable statute and controlling decisions rather than treating one jurisdiction’s rule as universal.