Orienting a Case Analysis
A practical approach to orienting case analysis by identifying the court, procedural posture, and opinion that controls.
Court, Posture, and the Opinion to Read
Begin with the court and posture
Before analyzing a case’s reasoning, record the court, date, parties, and . In particular, identify what happened in the lower court and which ruling the present court is reviewing. This context tells you what question is before the court. An appellate court may review a particular ruling rather than retry the whole dispute, so do not assume its decision addresses every issue in the case. The posture helps define both the legal issue and the reach of the decision.
Read in two passes
On an initial read, note the result and the opinion’s broad subject. This gives you an overview without confusing the outcome with the reasoning behind it. On a closer read, trace the court’s analysis: mark the facts it relies on, the legal question it answers, the rule it applies, and the steps connecting that rule to its result. These elements help explain not just what the court decided, but how it reached the decision and what the decision covers.
Pay particular attention to the when identifying the controlling rule. A concurrence or dissent can clarify where judges agree or disagree, but it does not necessarily state the rule that controls the court’s decision. Read those opinions as additional perspectives, while keeping the majority’s reasoning central to identifying the holding and its scope.