Timedora

Sources and Authority of U.S. Law

Explains major sources of U.S. law, their authority, and how federal and state law interact.

How Legal Sources Relate

Four common sources of law

U.S. law comes from several sources that relate to one another in different ways:

  • Constitutions set limits on government power and establish governmental structures. The U.S. Constitution establishes the federal system; state constitutions govern state institutions, subject to federal supremacy.

  • Statutes are laws enacted by Congress or state legislatures within their authority.

  • Regulations are rules agencies issue under authority delegated by statutes. An agency cannot use a to exceed that delegated authority.

  • Judicial decisions interpret constitutions, statutes, and regulations. They can guide how those sources are understood and applied.

These sources do not form one simple ladder in which every item always overrides every other. Their authority depends on the issue and the legal system involved. For example, a must be supported by statutory authority; it is not an independent power to make rules without limits.

How court decisions guide later cases

A court generally must follow binding decisions from higher courts in its own system. Decisions from another jurisdiction may help persuade a court, but they are not necessarily binding. So, when considering a decision, ask both which court issued it and whether that court’s ruling binds the court now deciding the issue.

When federal law controls

The makes valid federal law controlling when it governs an issue and conflicts with state law. This does not mean federal law automatically displaces state law. First determine whether federal law applies to the issue, then whether there is an actual conflict or preemption. The key is whether federal law governs and either conflicts with state law or preempts it—not merely that one rule is federal and the other is state.

Finally, keep two questions distinct: which court may hear a case, and which law governs it. A court’s authority to hear a dispute does not, by itself, decide which jurisdiction’s substantive law applies.