What is the purpose of comparing policy options?
It shows how well each alternative meets a defined need and what trade-offs achieving that entails.
Study 3 Criteria and Methods for Comparing Options with 12 free online flashcards. Review key terms, definitions, and concepts with this interactive flashcard deck.
What is the purpose of comparing policy options?
It shows how well each alternative meets a defined need and what trade-offs achieving that entails.
What is a criterion in policy appraisal?
A criterion is a specific aspect of performance, derived from policy objectives, that can be used to compare alternatives.
How do minimum requirements differ from trade-off criteria?
Minimum requirements are pass/fail thresholds; trade-off criteria can be weighed against one another once options meet the basic requirements.
What does swing weighting compare?
Swing weighting compares the practical change from worst to best performance on each criterion, then judges the value of that change.
What does threshold screening do?
Threshold screening removes options that fail defined legal, safety, or minimum-performance requirements.
Why should a weighted-score total not be treated as the decision?
A weighted total or ranking should not decide the matter by itself; arbitrary scales or weights can obscure assumptions and reduce transparency.
How should decision-makers test whether a preferred option is robust?
Test whether conclusions change when key assumptions, weights, or forecasts change; if a small change reverses the ranking, report that sensitivity.
Why include a baseline in an options comparison?
A baseline, such as continuing current policy, shows the effects of proposed options against what would otherwise happen.
What kinds of performance can policy criteria assess?
They can cover effectiveness, equity, cost and value, feasibility, and risks or wider effects.
How should criteria be defined for a fair comparison?
Define each criterion precisely, specify its evidence or indicator, and avoid counting the same effect more than once.
What should decision-makers remember about criterion weights?
Weights are judgments, not universal measurements of importance; document their rationale and relevant stakeholder differences.
When is cost-benefit analysis useful?
Cost-benefit analysis estimates and compares costs and benefits in monetary terms when they can be valued credibly.
Explore how geography, chronology, evidence, and networks shaped the diverse societies of the ancient Mediterranean.
A medium-difficulty quiz on Renaissance humanism, artistic practices, political life, patronage, and the movement’s varied forms across Europe.
A medium-difficulty quiz on the Reformation, Catholic reform, and the political settlements and changes that shaped religious life in Europe.
Trace how Greek communities developed into independent poleis and compare the distinct political and social paths of Sparta and Athens during the Archaic Age.
Compare political power and citizenship in Athens and Sparta, then trace how the Persian Wars and rival alliances shaped Greek warfare and the Peloponnesian War.
Explore how religion, philosophy, performance, art, architecture, and social life shaped diverse ancient Greek communities.
Trace Macedon’s rise, Alexander’s conquests, the competing successor kingdoms, and the political, social, religious, and artistic connections that shaped the Hellenistic Mediterranean.
Review Rome’s early origins, republican institutions, social reforms, and expansion across Italy.
A medium-difficulty quiz on Rome's Mediterranean expansion, provincial government, and the pressures that destabilized the Republic.
Trace how Rome’s Mediterranean conquests expanded its power and strained Republican institutions, from the Punic Wars to Augustus’s new political settlement.
A medium-difficulty quiz on Roman imperial government, provincial administration, and the army.
A medium-difficulty quiz on Roman religion, social relationships, labor, trade, and urban life.