True or false: Including continuation of current policy as a baseline can help decision-makers judge the effects of proposed options against what would otherwise happen.
3 Criteria and Methods for Comparing Options Online Quiz Questions
Use this free practice quiz with 20 questions to review 3 Criteria and Methods for Comparing Options, test your knowledge, and prepare for your next test or exam.
A policy objective is to improve equitable access to a service. Which is the clearest criterion for comparing options against that objective?
- A
Whether the policy objective is generally important to the agency
- B
The change in service access for a specified underserved group
- C
Whether decision-makers like the option
- D
The number of alternatives under consideration
What approach prioritizes criteria by comparing the practical change from worst to best performance on each one and judging how valuable that change is?
Two programs pursue the same outcome. The outcome can be measured consistently, but it cannot be reliably valued in money. Which method best compares their costs against that outcome?
- A
Cost-benefit analysis, because it monetizes all outcomes
- B
Threshold screening, because it compares the cost per outcome
- C
Cost-effectiveness analysis, because it compares costs for a shared measurable outcome
- D
Multi-criteria decision analysis, because it converts all criteria into money
Which practices help make criteria useful for comparing policy options? Select all that apply.
- A
Link criteria to the policy objectives and concerns of affected groups
- B
Avoid counting the same effect more than once
- C
Use the same fixed criteria for every policy decision, regardless of its objectives
- D
Specify the evidence or indicator that will be used
True or false: Multi-criteria decision analysis can organize options against both qualitative and quantitative criteria.
- A
True
- B
False
In a cost-effectiveness comparison of options that pursue a shared outcome, what concise cost measure does the example use for an additional service user?
Which statement best describes a limitation of cost-benefit analysis?
- A
CBA is only appropriate when every effect can be valued precisely in money
- B
CBA compares costs and benefits in monetary terms where credible valuation is possible, while acknowledging that some effects may be hard to value
- C
CBA is the same as threshold screening because both eliminate options that fail a minimum requirement
- D
CBA should replace detailed appraisal whenever a shortlist has been formed
Which practices make a policy-option comparison easier to review and scrutinize? Select all that apply.
- A
State the options and baseline being compared
- B
Present a single ranking without explaining assumptions or evidence
- C
Identify data sources and assumptions
- D
Show uncertainty and test whether conclusions change under key assumptions
A policy team is preparing a comparison to support a decision among several options. Describe the key steps it should take to make the comparison defensible and reviewable, including how it should handle mandatory requirements, uncertainty, and possible changes in the conclusion.
A policy option fails an essential safety standard but scores highly on cost and effectiveness. How should the safety standard affect the comparison?
- A
A high score on other criteria can compensate for failing the threshold.
- B
An option that fails a mandatory requirement should be screened out, regardless of its scores on other criteria.
- C
The threshold makes it unnecessary to compare options on any other criteria.
- D
The threshold ensures every option receives the same overall score.
If an option fails a mandatory safety standard, a high score on other criteria should be enough to keep it eligible for selection.
- A
True
- B
False
When designing criteria for comparing policy options, which practice helps prevent the same impact from being given undue influence?
- A
Count the effect under several criteria so it has more influence in the comparison.
- B
Avoid counting the same effect more than once across the criteria.
- C
Use only criteria that can be expressed in monetary terms.
- D
Set criteria after identifying which option is preferred.
A decision team must compare the cost of several options that pursue the same outcome. The outcome can be measured consistently, but not reliably assigned a monetary value. What comparison method best fits this situation?
A team has credible monetary estimates for the costs and benefits of competing options and wants to compare them in monetary terms. Which method is most appropriate?
- A
Use cost-benefit analysis when costs and benefits can be credibly compared in monetary terms
- B
Use cost-effectiveness analysis to assign a monetary value to every effect
- C
Use threshold screening to rank options by their total monetary benefits
- D
Use MCDA only when every criterion is measured in money
A health agency is comparing text reminders, transport vouchers, and mobile clinics to reduce missed appointments. Which approach best reflects a balanced comparison of the options?
- A
Select text reminders because low cost should decide the comparison
- B
Compare expected access effects across groups alongside costs and delivery demands
- C
Choose mobile clinics because reaching the greatest-barrier group overrides all other concerns
- D
Exclude staffing demands because they are not relevant to policy outcomes
What method organizes policy options against multiple qualitative and quantitative criteria to make trade-offs explicit?
A policy team needs to compare options using both qualitative and quantitative criteria. Which use of multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) is most defensible?
- A
Treat the option with the highest weighted score as the decision, regardless of its impacts
- B
Use MCDA only when all criteria have a common monetary measure
- C
Replace detailed appraisal with a single performance matrix
- D
Use MCDA to organize evidence across criteria, while treating rankings as aids to—not substitutes for—decision-making
An agency tests a key forecast and finds that a small change reverses which policy option ranks first. The agency should report that the preferred choice is to that assumption, rather than present the ranking as certain.
A health agency is planning transport vouchers to help patients attend appointments. Besides estimating the voucher cost, it should plan the needed to determine who qualifies and to provide the vouchers.
Related study packs and tools
- Quiz
01 The Ancient Mediterranean: Geography, Sources, and Chronology
Explore how geography, chronology, evidence, and networks shaped the diverse societies of the ancient Mediterranean.
- Quiz
01 The Renaissance in Europe
A medium-difficulty quiz on Renaissance humanism, artistic practices, political life, patronage, and the movement’s varied forms across Europe.
- Quiz
02 The Reformation and Religious Change
A medium-difficulty quiz on the Reformation, Catholic reform, and the political settlements and changes that shaped religious life in Europe.
- Study guide
03 The Greek Polis and the Archaic Age
Trace how Greek communities developed into independent poleis and compare the distinct political and social paths of Sparta and Athens during the Archaic Age.
- Study guide
04 Greek Politics and Warfare in the Classical Age
Compare political power and citizenship in Athens and Sparta, then trace how the Persian Wars and rival alliances shaped Greek warfare and the Peloponnesian War.
- Study guide
05 Greek Religion, Society, and Culture
Explore how religion, philosophy, performance, art, architecture, and social life shaped diverse ancient Greek communities.
- Study guide
06 Macedon and the Hellenistic Mediterranean
Trace Macedon’s rise, Alexander’s conquests, the competing successor kingdoms, and the political, social, religious, and artistic connections that shaped the Hellenistic Mediterranean.
- Flashcards
07 Early Rome and the Republic
Review Rome’s early origins, republican institutions, social reforms, and expansion across Italy.
- Quiz
08 Rome’s Mediterranean Expansion and Republican Crisis
A medium-difficulty quiz on Rome's Mediterranean expansion, provincial government, and the pressures that destabilized the Republic.
- Study guide
08 Rome’s Mediterranean Expansion and Republican Crisis
Trace how Rome’s Mediterranean conquests expanded its power and strained Republican institutions, from the Punic Wars to Augustus’s new political settlement.
- Quiz
09 The Roman Empire: Government and Warfare
A medium-difficulty quiz on Roman imperial government, provincial administration, and the army.
- Quiz
10 Roman Society, Religion, and Economy
A medium-difficulty quiz on Roman religion, social relationships, labor, trade, and urban life.