1 Framing Policy Problems and Objectives
Learn how to define an evidence-based policy problem, identify affected groups, set objectives, and establish a clear scope for analysis.
Define the
A sound policy analysis begins by clarifying what is happening, who is affected, what change is sought, and what the analysis will cover. These choices shape which alternatives are considered and how they are compared. Framing should be led by evidence: defining a problem to fit a preferred solution risks overlooking causes or excluding better responses.
A is more than a visible condition or a statement of dissatisfaction. Define it in terms of the harm, unmet need, or gap between current and desired outcomes, and explain why public action may be relevant.
A useful problem definition describes:
The condition, its scale, where it occurs, and how often.
The causes and mechanisms that produce or sustain it, distinguishing underlying causes from visible symptoms.
The consequences, including the harms or costs and the people who experience them.
Why government action might help and what government can plausibly influence.
The : what is likely to happen if current arrangements continue.
Use quantitative evidence where appropriate and qualitative evidence to explain experiences and mechanisms. State uncertainty and evidence gaps rather than presenting assumptions as facts. A problem may affect groups differently, and some aspects may be beyond government’s practical ability to change.
For example, “too many cars” describes a condition but does not by itself establish the causes or the problem to address. If evidence indicates that long and unreliable commutes result mainly from infrequent bus service and poorly connected routes, focusing only on restricting cars may miss important causes and alternatives.
Identify
Identify who experience the problem, may benefit or bear costs from possible responses, or have a role in delivering them. Consider who is affected directly and indirectly, where they are, and how many may be affected. Assess the severity and frequency of effects for different groups.
Impacts may be unequal by income, age, disability, occupation, or other relevant characteristics. Also identify organizations, service providers, and levels of government that influence the problem or would implement a response.
Do not treat “the public” or “businesses” as uniform groups. Disaggregating impacts can show who benefits, who faces burdens, and whose perspective is missing. Stakeholder engagement can improve understanding, but assess evidence critically rather than assuming that one group’s account represents everyone’s experience.
Set policy objectives
A states the desired change, not the instrument selected to bring it about. Keep the problem separate from the solution: “reduce preventable injuries” is an objective, whereas “install speed cameras” is a proposed measure.
Objectives can describe:
Outcomes: changes in conditions or wellbeing, such as fewer serious road injuries. Outcomes clarify the ultimate purpose.
Outputs: goods or services delivered, such as additional road-safety inspections. Outputs can help track implementation.
Objectives should be specific enough to guide analysis and later evaluation. Where feasible, state the affected population and place, a measurable indicator, the intended direction or size of change, and a timeframe. For example: “Reduce serious road injuries among pedestrians in the city by 15% within five years.” Justify the target through evidence and feasibility rather than choosing it merely because it is easy to measure. Use a small, coherent set of objectives to keep the analysis focused.
Establish the
The sets the boundaries of the question being examined. State the relevant geography and population; historical evidence and future time period; policy domain and actions or institutions under consideration; intended and unintended impacts, including distributional effects; legal, operational, evidential, or resource constraints; and any exclusions.
Specify the against which alternatives will be compared, such as current policy or a “do minimum” situation. An explicit helps distinguish the effects of policy from what would happen anyway.
Make the broad enough to capture the main causes, , and plausible consequences, but clear enough to keep the work manageable. Match the depth of analysis to the problem’s significance and likely impacts. Record boundaries and assumptions, and revise them if early evidence shows that the initial framing misses an important cause or group. A clear problem definition, affected-group analysis, objectives, and together create a foundation for developing and comparing alternatives.