What does the but-for test ask?
The but-for test asks whether the result would have occurred when and as it did without the defendant’s conduct. If not, the conduct is ordinarily a factual cause.
Study Causation in Criminal Law with 12 free online flashcards. Review key terms, definitions, and concepts with this interactive flashcard deck.
What does the but-for test ask?
The but-for test asks whether the result would have occurred when and as it did without the defendant’s conduct. If not, the conduct is ordinarily a factual cause.
What is a result element?
A result element is a consequence the offense requires, such as death for homicide. The prosecution must prove the specified result and any required causal connection.
Does proof of causation alone establish guilt for a result offense?
No. The prosecution must separately prove that the defendant caused the prohibited result and had the mental state the offense requires regarding that result.
What does legal causation assess?
Legal causation asks whether the connection is sufficiently close under the applicable jurisdiction’s rule to attribute the result to the defendant. Courts may consider foreseeability, remoteness, and whether the causal chain was broken.
Why can two independently sufficient causes complicate but-for analysis?
Ordinary but-for analysis may be difficult when each cause could independently produce the result. Some jurisdictions use a substantial-factor or other multiple-cause rule; no single approach applies everywhere.
How does a result offense differ from a conduct offense?
A result offense requires a specified consequence, such as death or bodily injury. A conduct offense criminalizes prohibited conduct even if the intended harm does not occur.
What is an intervening cause?
An intervening cause is an event occurring after the defendant’s conduct and before the result. It does not automatically relieve the defendant of responsibility; its effect depends on the applicable legal test and circumstances.
When may a difference between contemplated and actual results defeat liability under the Model Penal Code approach?
Under the Model Penal Code approach, a difference between the actual result and the result contemplated or risked may defeat liability if it makes the actual result too remote or accidental to support it.
What causation rule did Burrage apply to the federal “death results” enhancement?
In Burrage, the federal “death results” enhancement at issue required but-for causation when the distributed drug was not independently sufficient to cause death.
Must the defendant always be the sole cause of a result?
No. Concurrent causes may contribute alongside the defendant’s conduct; the defendant need not always be the sole cause. The statute may nevertheless require a particular causal standard.
How do you identify the result element in a result offense?
Identify the consequence the statute requires, such as death for homicide or serious bodily injury for an offense requiring that injury.
A victim dies from poison. When is the poisoning a factual cause?
If the victim would not have died at that time without the poison, the poisoning is ordinarily a factual cause of the death under the but-for test.
Explore how geography, chronology, evidence, and networks shaped the diverse societies of the ancient Mediterranean.
A medium-difficulty quiz on Renaissance humanism, artistic practices, political life, patronage, and the movement’s varied forms across Europe.
Review the cultures, palace systems, writing, and social changes that shaped the Aegean world before the Greek city-states.
A medium-difficulty quiz on the Reformation, Catholic reform, and the political settlements and changes that shaped religious life in Europe.
Trace how Greek communities developed into independent poleis and compare the distinct political and social paths of Sparta and Athens during the Archaic Age.
Compare political power and citizenship in Athens and Sparta, then trace how the Persian Wars and rival alliances shaped Greek warfare and the Peloponnesian War.
Explore how religion, philosophy, performance, art, architecture, and social life shaped diverse ancient Greek communities.
Trace Macedon’s rise, Alexander’s conquests, the competing successor kingdoms, and the political, social, religious, and artistic connections that shaped the Hellenistic Mediterranean.
A medium-difficulty quiz on Rome's Mediterranean expansion, provincial government, and the pressures that destabilized the Republic.
Trace how Rome’s Mediterranean conquests expanded its power and strained Republican institutions, from the Punic Wars to Augustus’s new political settlement.
A medium-difficulty quiz on Roman imperial government, provincial administration, and the army.
A medium-difficulty quiz on Roman religion, social relationships, labor, trade, and urban life.