Timedora
Free Online Flashcard Deck

Criminal Act Requirement: Voluntary Acts, Omissions, and Possession Free Online Flashcards

Study Criminal Act Requirement: Voluntary Acts, Omissions, and Possession with 12 free online flashcards. Review key terms, definitions, and concepts with this interactive flashcard deck.

12 cards
01
Front

How did Robinson and Powell distinguish status from conduct?

Back

Robinson v. California barred punishment merely for narcotics addiction status; Powell v. Texas upheld a public-drunkenness conviction on the record before it, distinguishing status from conduct on a particular occasion.

02
Front

Under the MPC, what is the significance of a reflexive bodily movement?

Back

Under the MPC, reflexes and bodily movements during unconsciousness or sleep are not voluntary acts. The focus is bodily control, not whether a choice was wise.

03
Front

What generally must be shown for criminal liability based on an omission?

Back

Generally, omission liability requires a legal duty to act and proof of the offense’s remaining elements, including any required mental state and result. A moral expectation alone is insufficient.

04
Front

When can possession count as an act under the MPC?

Back

Under the MPC, possession counts as an act if the person knowingly obtained or received the item, or knew of control over it long enough to have a reasonable opportunity to end that control.

05
Front

How does the criminal act requirement differ from mens rea?

Back

The act requirement concerns whether conduct attributable to the accused occurred; mens rea concerns the required mental state. An intentional mental state cannot supply a missing voluntary act.

06
Front

What forms can the conduct requirement take?

Back

Criminal liability ordinarily requires conduct attributable to the accused: a voluntary act, a legally significant omission, or possession treated as conduct.

07
Front

What did Martin v. State illustrate about forced movement?

Back

In Martin v. State, police forced Martin from his home onto a public highway. The court held that officers’ forced movement could not be treated as Martin’s voluntary appearance there.

08
Front

What distinction explains the outcomes in Robinson and Powell?

Back

Robinson barred punishment merely for narcotics addiction status. Powell upheld a public-drunkenness conviction on the record before it, treating the charge as conduct on a particular occasion rather than status alone.

09
Front

Does a passerby’s moral reason to help, alone, usually establish omission liability?

Back

Usually not by itself. Seeing a stranger in danger may create a moral reason to help, but omission liability generally requires a legal duty to act.

10
Front

How do actual and constructive possession differ?

Back

Actual possession means physically holding the item. Constructive possession involves sufficient knowledge and control over an item located elsewhere; the exact test depends on the law applied.

11
Front

Can an intentional mental state replace a missing voluntary act?

Back

No. The act requirement and mens rea are distinct: an intentional mental state does not provide a voluntary act that is otherwise missing.

12
Front

What distinction did Powell draw between status and conduct?

Back

The constitutional distinction is between punishing a person merely for a status and punishing prohibited conduct on a particular occasion. Powell upheld the conviction on the record before it.