Timedora

Justification and Excuse

Clarifies the difference between claiming that conduct was legally permissible and claiming that wrongful conduct should be excused from criminal responsibility.

Was the conduct permissible, or wrongful but excusable?

Ask what the defense says about the conduct

A says that conduct that would otherwise satisfy a criminal offense was legally permissible under the circumstances. The claim is not simply that the actor made an understandable mistake: it is that the force or other action was justified.

An takes a different position. It accepts that the conduct was wrongful, but argues that the actor should not be held criminally responsible. In short, justification challenges whether the conduct was impermissible; accepts the wrongdoing and contests the actor’s responsibility for it.

The rules for these defenses vary by jurisdiction, so the precise requirements can differ.