Assessing Contract Formation
A source-grounded guide to assessing contract formation through objective agreement, offer and acceptance, consideration, and related limits on enforceability.
Agreement, exchange, and enforceability
Start with what the parties communicated
Contract formation asks whether the parties made an agreement the law recognizes. is assessed objectively: what would a reasonable person understand from the parties’ outward words and conduct? Private thoughts that were never expressed do not by themselves establish agreement. Assent can appear in spoken or written words, or be inferred from conduct. For example, knowingly accepting an ordered service may indicate agreement to pay; it does not automatically settle every question about whether a contract was formed.
An offer communicates willingness to make a bargain in a way that gives the other person reason to understand that accepting will conclude the deal. A statement that leaves the speaker free to decide later may instead invite further discussion. Acceptance is assent to the offer and must use the method the offer requires or one reasonably expected in the circumstances. Under the common-law mirror-image rule, changing the offer’s terms generally makes the response a counteroffer rather than an acceptance.
Work through the exchange
Suppose a homeowner asks a painter to paint a house for $2,000. If the painter clearly offers that work for that price and the homeowner accepts, their words show . The homeowner’s promise to pay and the painter’s promise to do the work are for each other: each is given in exchange for the other. Courts generally do not require the exchanged items to have equal economic value. By contrast, “I may hire you” may express only uncertainty, not an offer that can be accepted; without a formed bargain, the promised payment and work are not an exchanged pair of contractual promises.
Check the applicable rules and other requirements
The general pattern is offer and acceptance showing , supported by . Enforceability can also depend on capacity, legality, and other rules. The precise rules vary with contract type and governing state law. Common-law rules generally govern services and real estate. Sales of goods are governed by Article 2 of the UCC as adopted by states; those rules can recognize a contract through conduct showing agreement even if the exact moment of formation is unclear or some terms remain open, provided the parties intended to contract and there is a reasonably certain basis for a remedy.