2 Externalities and Market Failure
Learn how external costs and benefits affect market output, social welfare, and the quantity of goods that is allocatively efficient.
Externalities and social effects
An is a cost or benefit from producing or consuming a good that affects people who are not part of the market transaction. Since market prices do not fully reflect these effects, buyers and sellers may make decisions that fail to maximize total social welfare.
The effects can be separated by who bears a cost or receives a benefit. A or is borne or received by the buyer or seller directly involved. An external cost or benefit falls on or accrues to third parties, while and include both private and external effects.
Marginal social costs and benefits
Marginal measures compare the cost or benefit to society of producing or consuming one additional unit. combines marginal with marginal external cost:
combines marginal with marginal external benefit:
Here, and are and benefit; and are marginal and benefit; and and are marginal external cost and benefit.
Negative externalities and overproduction
A imposes an uncompensated cost on third parties. For example, a factory may pay for its labor and materials while nearby residents bear some health or property costs from pollution. Noise that disturbs neighbors is another example.
Because decision-makers do not bear the full cost, is lower than . In the factory example, this means exceeds marginal :
In a competitive market, quantity is determined by private benefits and costs, where marginal equals marginal :
If there are no other market problems, the socially efficient quantity is where equals . With a negative production , the private market typically produces more than this efficient quantity because producers do not bear the full .
Positive externalities and underproduction
A provides an uncompensated benefit to third parties. Someone who gets vaccinated benefits directly, while other people may also benefit because transmission becomes less likely. Research and innovation can also create spillover benefits when other firms or consumers gain from knowledge the innovator cannot fully capture.
The buyer may consider the without accounting for the full benefit to others. As a result, exceeds marginal :
Because private decision-makers capture only part of the total benefit, a market with a typically supplies or consumes less than the socially efficient quantity. Between the market quantity and the efficient quantity, the benefits to society from additional units exceed their social costs. Those units are not produced or consumed, so potential net gains are lost.
occurs when resources are directed toward the mix and quantity of goods that create the greatest net benefit for society. In the basic marginal-analysis model, the efficient quantity satisfies:
If is greater than , producing another unit adds to social welfare. If is greater, producing another unit reduces social welfare.
Market equilibrium may differ from the efficient quantity because market prices reflect private costs and benefits, not necessarily all social costs and benefits. A tends to cause overproduction, while a tends to cause underproduction.
from inefficient output
is not simply money transferred between parties. It represents the net value of beneficial exchanges that do not occur, or the net costs imposed by extra units whose social costs exceed their benefits.
With a , the units produced between the efficient quantity and the larger market quantity create : for each such unit, the cost to society exceeds its benefit. On a standard supply-and-demand graph, this loss is the area between the social-cost and benefit curves over the excess output; with straight-line curves, the area appears as a triangle.
With a , the missing units between the market quantity and the efficient quantity would have benefits to society greater than their social costs. On a standard graph, the resulting is the area between the social-benefit and cost curves over the missing output.
Comparing private and social effects
Suppose a polluting producer makes an additional unit that costs the producer and causes of harm to others. Its is , but its is . If the unit benefits consumers by , it appears worthwhile when only is considered, since exceeds . But it reduces total welfare because its benefit is less than its .
Conversely, suppose a vaccination gives its recipient a benefit of and provides an additional benefit of to others. Its is . A decision based only on the recipient's benefit may overlook worthwhile additional vaccinations.