3 Public Goods and Common Resources
Learn how excludability and rivalry distinguish public goods, common resources, private goods, and club goods, and why these differences can lead to free-riding or overuse.
Two properties for classifying goods
Goods can be classified by asking two questions: can people be excluded from using them, and does one person’s use reduce what is available to others? These properties help explain why some goods invite free-riding while some shared resources are overused.
is the ability to prevent someone from using a good, often by requiring payment. means that one person’s use leaves less of the good, or less opportunity to use it, for others.
Four categories of goods
The two properties create four basic categories:
: nonexcludable and nonrivalrous; national defense is an example.
: nonexcludable and rivalrous; fish in an open-access fishery are an example.
Private good: excludable and rivalrous; a meal is an example.
Club good: excludable and nonrivalrous, at least until congestion; subscription streaming is an example.
These categories are useful starting points. In practice, exclusion and can vary by degree or change with congestion.
Public goods and free-riding
A is nonexcludable and nonrivalrous. When it is available, one person’s benefit does not substantially prevent others from benefiting too. For example, people in a country benefit from national defense whether or not each person pays directly for it.
This can create a : someone can benefit while hoping others will cover the cost. If enough people act this way, a private seller may be unable to collect enough payment to provide the good, or the good may be provided in too small a quantity. Public funding through taxation is one way to address the problem by spreading the cost among beneficiaries.
Common resources and overuse
A is nonexcludable but rivalrous. People may be difficult to keep out, but each person’s use reduces what remains for others. In an open-access fishery, for example, a fish caught by one fisher cannot be caught by another.
When access is not effectively limited, each user may gain from taking more while sharing the resulting depletion with everyone else. This incentive can lead to overuse, such as catching too many fish for the stock to recover. This pattern is often called the .
Catch limits, permits, or locally agreed access arrangements can help manage use and protect the resource.
Underprovision and overuse
The central challenge for public goods is that people can benefit without paying, which can lead to underprovision. For common resources, people can use a shared resource without being excluded, and because use is rival, this can lead to overuse.
In short, public goods may be difficult to fund privately, while unregulated access to common resources may encourage depletion or congestion.