Compensatory Damages and Proof
How compensatory damages aim to restore a plaintiff for proven losses, and what evidence may be needed to support recovery.
What Cover
The restorative aim
—also called actual damages—aim to restore the plaintiff, as nearly as money can, to the position they would have been in had the tort not occurred. They address proven losses; they are not simply an amount chosen to punish the defendant.
The losses may be economic or noneconomic. Economic losses include reasonable medical expenses, lost wages, reduced future earning capacity, and costs to repair or replace damaged property. Noneconomic losses may include pain and suffering, emotional distress, and loss of enjoyment of life, when the law permits those categories and the evidence supports them.
Why proof matters
A plaintiff must support claimed losses with appropriate evidence. For example, listing medical expenses or lost wages is not, by itself, proof of their amount. The evidence must support the loss being claimed. Future losses, such as reduced earning capacity, may also be recoverable, but only if established with sufficient proof; a possibility alone does not establish the amount of a future loss.
The restorative goal helps explain why the calculation depends on the loss: medical expenses address treatment costs, while lost wages address income already missed. But the goal does not mean that every asserted loss is automatically recoverable. Which categories are allowed, how damages are calculated, and what evidence is admissible depend on the jurisdiction. Thus, a damages claim requires both identifying a legally permitted loss and supporting it with appropriate evidence.