Timedora

Factual Cause in Negligence

Learn how factual causation connects a negligence breach to harm, including the but-for test, multiple contributing causes, and cases where an alternative test may apply.

Did the Breach Contribute to the Harm?

: the but-for question

asks whether the defendant’s breach actually contributed to the harm. The usual test is: Would the harm have occurred but for the breach? To apply it, consider the situation without the breach. If the harm would not have happened, the breach is a under this test.

Worked example: red-light collision. A driver runs a red light and strikes a cyclist. Ask whether the collision would have happened if the driver had obeyed the light. If not, the violation is a of the cyclist’s injuries. The question is about contribution to the harm; the breach need not be the only cause.

When there is more than one cause

Several negligent acts may contribute to one injury, and each may be a . The but-for test becomes harder, however, when two independent causes would each have been sufficient on their own to produce the same harm. Removing either cause from the imagined scenario would still leave the other, sufficient cause, so the ordinary test may not resolve the issue straightforwardly.

In some such cases, courts may use an alternative approach, such as a substantial-factor formulation. That is not a universal replacement: the governing formulation depends on the jurisdiction. So, when analyzing , first apply the usual but-for question, then recognize the special difficulty posed by independently sufficient causes and check which rule governs.