Selecting and Implementing a Superfund Remedy
How Superfund teams define cleanup objectives, compare alternatives, and document a remedy decision under the NCP.
Set objectives and build alternatives
Set objectives before comparing technologies
A cleanup team first defines : what the remedy must accomplish, which environmental media and contaminants it addresses, and the time frame for doing so. For example, objectives might include preventing exposure to contaminated soil, stopping contaminated groundwater from migrating, or restoring an aquifer to specified cleanup levels. These objectives make clear what a successful remedy needs to achieve before the team compares ways to achieve it.
The team then develops alternatives designed to meet the objectives. An alternative can combine actions such as source control, treatment, containment, exposure controls, and monitoring. Different actions may also apply in different parts of a site or proceed in phases. This matters because one technology may not address every objective: controlling a contaminant source, limiting exposure, and managing groundwater movement can require different actions. Comparing complete alternatives—not treating “cleanup” as a single undifferentiated outcome—helps show how each strategy addresses the site’s needs.
Evaluate trade-offs and document the choice
| Category | Criterion | Question to consider |
|---|---|---|
| Threshold | Overall protection | Does it adequately control unacceptable risks? |
| Threshold | ARAR compliance | Does it meet pertinent requirements, or qualify for a justified waiver? |
| Primary balancing | Long-term effectiveness and permanence | How reliably will it protect over time? |
| Primary balancing | Treatment reducing toxicity, mobility, or volume | How much does treatment permanently reduce hazards, movement, or quantity? |
| Primary balancing | Short-term effectiveness | What risks or disruptions arise, and how soon is protection achieved? |
| Primary balancing | Implementability | Can it be designed, permitted, built, operated, and maintained? |
| Primary balancing | Cost | What are the costs over time? |
| Modifying | State acceptance | What are the state regulator’s views? |
| Modifying | Community acceptance | What does the community support, question, or oppose? |
Evaluate trade-offs and document the choice
Under the National Oil and Hazardous Substances Pollution Contingency Plan (NCP), the decision proceeds in stages. First, the two determine eligibility: an alternative must protect human health and the environment and comply with applicable or relevant and appropriate requirements (ARARs), unless a waiver is justified. Next, the five compare eligible alternatives. They weigh long-term effectiveness and permanence, treatment’s reduction of toxicity, mobility, or volume, short-term effectiveness, implementability, and cost. Finally, state and community acceptance are modifying criteria considered as the decision is finalized after review and comment. They inform the choice rather than replace the threshold screening or balancing comparison.
Cost must be considered alongside overall effectiveness. A lower-cost alternative is not automatically preferable if it provides substantially less protection or permanence.
Consider the source’s example of contaminated soil above a shallow groundwater plume. Excavating and treating the most contaminated soil may reduce the source quickly, but construction can create worker, traffic, and dust risks. A cap may reduce exposure and infiltration with less disruption, but leaves contamination in place and needs long-term inspection and maintenance. Groundwater extraction and treatment may control plume migration, yet restoration can take a long time and require ongoing operation. Each option therefore has different strengths and limitations; none should be judged by speed or removal alone.
A combined alternative—source treatment, a cap over residual contamination, groundwater treatment, and exposure controls—may meet the objectives better than any single technology. The comparison should make these trade-offs explicit. The selected remedy and how the criteria informed the choice are documented in a Record of Decision (ROD). This framework describes the U.S. Superfund process under CERCLA and the NCP; other cleanup programs may use different decision procedures.