First-Law Energy Balances for Closed Systems
A practical lesson on applying the first law to closed systems, interpreting heat and work transfers, and checking energy-balance calculations.
The closed-system balance and its signs
What makes the system closed?
A closed system contains a fixed amount of matter: mass does not cross its boundary. Energy can still cross that boundary as or . This distinction matters because the first law accounts for energy transferred in or out and for changes in the energy held by the system.
and are not properties stored in a system. They describe energy transfers during a process. , by contrast, is a property of the system’s state. With the sign convention used here, entering the system is positive, and done by the system is positive. Therefore, done on the system is negative.
Start with the full balance
For a process from state 1 to state 2, the first law is
Here, and account for changes in kinetic and potential energy. Keep them in the balance unless the problem justifies treating them as negligible. If changes in speed and elevation are negligible, the balance reduces to
The minus sign before follows directly from the convention: done by the system carries energy out, while done on the system is recorded as negative . Subtracting a negative value therefore increases the energy change.
Track signs before calculating
Consider the source example: a closed system receives of and has of input. With the stated convention,
received: .
input is done on the system: .
Neglecting kinetic- and potential-energy changes, substitute the signed values:
The system’s increased by . The negative sign is essential: using for input would contradict the chosen convention. For several or transfers, first combine each kind into its net signed total, then apply the balance.
State change versus process path
The internal-energy change depends on the initial and final states. and generally depend on the process path between those states. In other words, the same endpoints determine the energy change, but they do not, by themselves, specify how much energy crossed the boundary as or as .
Transfers, , and a dependable setup
when the boundary moves
A moving boundary can transfer energy as . For a , the system pressure is defined throughout the motion, and the is
With done by the system defined as positive, expansion gives positive , while compression gives negative . On a pressure–volume (-) diagram, the integral is the signed area under the process curve: expansion contributes positive area and compression contributes negative area.
The quasi-equilibrium condition matters. More generally, the pressure opposing a moving boundary is the external pressure. Replacing that pressure with the system pressure requires the appropriate quasi-equilibrium assumption.
may not be the only transfer. Electrical or paddle-wheel , for example, can also contribute. Add the signed modes:
Each term is positive when is done by the system and negative when is done on it.
Worked example: constant-pressure expansion
A gas expands from to at a constant pressure of . Assume is the only mode. The volume change is
At constant pressure, the boundary- integral becomes pressure times the volume change:
The unit conversion is , and the positive result is consistent with expansion. If of enters and changes in kinetic and potential energy are negligible, then
The increases by : of the energy entering as , leaves as done by the gas, and the remaining increases its .
A dependable setup
Define the system and boundary. Draw or sketch the boundary, then verify that no mass crosses it; if mass does cross, the closed-system balance is not the appropriate setup.
Identify and sign each transfer. into the system is positive; done by the system is positive. input is negative. Combine multiple transfers into net signed totals.
Determine whether is needed. If the boundary moves, use the process information to calculate its . Use system pressure in the integral only when the quasi-equilibrium assumption applies; include other modes if present.
Write the full balance first: . Remove terms only when the conditions justify treating them as zero or negligible.
Check units, signs, and meaning. A positive means increased. Confirm that the sign of calculated agrees with the direction of the process, such as positive for expansion.