Timedora

Soil Shear Strength and Effective Stress

Explains how effective stress governs soil resistance and distinguishes drained strength from short-term undrained strength in saturated clay.

and Drained versus

Why pore pressure matters

Soil shear strength is its resistance to shearing, but it is not one fixed number. It varies with factors such as stress history, density, drainage, loading direction, and deformation. In saturated soil, total normal stress is shared by the soil skeleton and the water in its pores. The carried by the skeleton is

σ′=σ−u,\sigma' = \sigma - u,

where σ\sigma is total normal stress and uu is pore-water pressure. Because controls frictional resistance and much of soil deformation, a rise in pore pressure can lower and reduce available shear resistance.

For example, in a hypothetical case with total normal stress of 200 kPa and pore-water pressure of 80 kPa, is 200−80=120200-80=120 kPa. If total stress stays at 200 kPa while pore pressure rises to 110 kPa, becomes 90 kPa. This calculation isolates the effect of pressure; it does not by itself determine the soil’s strength.

Drained strength: the Mohr–Coulomb model

For drained shear, excess pore pressure is allowed to dissipate during shearing. A common model is

τf=c′+σn′tan⁡ϕ′,\tau_f = c' + \sigma_n'\tan\phi',

where τf\tau_f is shear stress at failure on the plane, σn′\sigma_n' is effective normal stress on that plane, c′c' is the effective cohesion intercept, and ϕ′\phi' is the effective friction angle. The equation represents a fitted strength envelope: its parameters are idealizations based on test results over a relevant stress range, not universal constants for every condition.

To see how the terms work, consider a hypothetical soil with c′=5c'=5 kPa, ϕ′=30∘\phi'=30^\circ, and σn′=120\sigma_n'=120 kPa. The model gives τf=5+120tan⁡(30∘)≈74\tau_f=5+120\tan(30^\circ)\approx74 kPa. If effective normal stress were instead 90 kPa, while the same fitted parameters remained applicable, the estimate would be about 57 kPa. The comparison shows the frictional contribution changing with effective normal stress. For many clean sands, c′c' is small; apparent cohesion should not automatically be assumed to represent permanent bonding.

Rapid loading:

When saturated, low-permeability clay is loaded rapidly, excess pore pressure may not dissipate during loading. Engineers often describe this short-term behavior with undrained shear strength sus_u in a total-stress analysis. A simplified model may take ϕu≈0\phi_u\approx0, so strength is represented approximately by sus_u.

This is a practical model for specified conditions—not a claim that effective-stress friction disappears. The drained Mohr–Coulomb parameters and the undrained-strength description are different ways of representing behavior under different drainage and analysis conditions. Choose the description to match the problem; do not treat one as a universal strength value or transfer fitted parameters beyond the conditions they represent.

  • : A model for drained shear strength: τ_f = c′ + σ_n′ tan φ′.